Skip to content
Sign up free
Live Live

Election night: get email alerts

Commentary

Alaska Democrats Won. Their Election Gamesmanship Didn't.

Alaska election results.
Image Credit: PX_Media on Dreamstime.com. License obtained and used by IVN Editor Shawn Griffiths.

In ranked choice voting elections, strategy games like recruiting same-name candidates or withdrawing candidates to manipulate the ballot don't work and can backfire on those attempting them.

By Kyle Bailey

4-minute read

Mary Peltola will be the next US Senator from Alaska, defeating Dan Sullivan. No, not that Dan Sullivan, the other one.

On October 28, six days before the general election, The New York Times published a story about the same-name candidate recruitment effort by some Democratic operatives in Alaska’s US Senate race.

You Can't Blame Alaska's 'Decoy Dan' On Ranked Choice Voting
Dirty tricks like recruiting same-name candidates to split votes has a history not limited to a single state or party. But it won't work in Alaska's US Senate race because the state uses ranked choice voting.

Both incumbent GOP US Senator Dan Sullivan and independent Daniel J. Sullivan competed in Alaska’s Top Four nonpartisan primary on August 18 and advanced to the general election, along with Peltola and another lesser-known Republican.

The case of the two Sullivans had drawn significant media attention months before the Times story. In fact, Alaska Republicans had tried and failed to have "Decoy Dan" removed from the general election ballot.

However, the Times story gave Republicans significant ammunition and sympathy for the GOP incumbent in the final days of the campaign. Republicans milked it for all that it was worth, and the national media was a willing accomplice.

(Remember that The New York Times also helped to break the story about FBI Director Comey reopening its investigation of Hillary Clinton’s emails days before the 2016 election, which many attribute at least in part to her loss.)

In the senatorial election, possibly as a result of gamesmanship by Democratic operatives, Peltola ran roughly 1,000 votes behind the Democratic nominee for governor, despite being much better known.

Ultimately, the same-name candidate recruitment and gamesmanship by Democratic operatives trying to aid Peltola left a bad taste in the mouths of Alaska voters. That may have cost Peltola some votes.

Had the race been razor-close, it could have cost her the election.

Alaska Democrats tried to manufacture victories. They won despite their missteps.

Following Alaska’s 2026 senatorial and gubernatorial Top Four nonpartisan primaries, the second-place Democratic candidates in both primaries withdrew as general election candidates. This pulled up the fifth-place finishers from each primary into the general election.

It was a clear attempt to further divide Republicans and consolidate support for a single Democratic candidate in both races. If Alaska had single-choice voting, that strategy would have been logical.

However, with ranked choice voting, it is fruitless and can actually backfire.

Some Democratic consultants operated in the 2026 Alaska races as if the state still had single-choice voting. Their antics may have lowered the overall Democratic vote total (1,000 votes in a rural state like Alaska is a lot of votes).

A lesson about candidate strategy in ranked choice voting elections from Maine.

Consider Maine’s 2018 election for US Congress in the second district. Incumbent GOP Rep. Bruce Poliquin was ahead of Democratic challenger Jared Golden in the first round of tabulation on election night. However, Poliquin finished under 50% in the four-way race, triggering an automatic runoff with ranked choice voting.

Golden and the two independent candidates in the race cross-endorsed one another and consistently made complimentary statements. Meanwhile, Poliquin told voters to rank only him and chastised the independent candidates as spoilers.

Not surprisingly, voters who ranked the independent candidates ahead of the party nominees preferred Golden over Poliquin by a two-to-one margin. That support catapulted Golden to victory in the final round of tabulation.

Without meaningful competition, choice, and cross-endorsements, Poliquin might have narrowly defeated Golden in that election.

In 2026, the Democratic nominee for this congressional seat (Golden retired) narrowly lost to the Republican in a head-to-head race with no independent candidates.

How Republicans Flipped a Key Congressional Race Despite the Blue Wave in Maine
If he had sought re-election, current incumbent Democrat Rep. Jared Golden would have beaten Republican Paul LePage and kept this seat in Democratic hands.

In ranked choice voting elections, independent and third-party candidates can drive voter interest and boost turnout. Party nominees who reach beyond their base and seek common ground and cross-endorsements with independent and third-party candidates can reap the rewards of humility and collaboration.

This same logic applies to Top Four general elections in which multiple candidates from the same political party appear on the ballot together. Because they will likely appeal to different factions within their party, they can drive interest in their races and increase voter turnout among like-minded voters.

By consolidating support through cross-endorsements, they can demonstrate their collaborative nature, which makes them better suited to leadership in the eyes of swing voters.

Sources

  1. The New York Times: Inside Democrats’ Secret Effort to Stack Alaska’s Ballot
  2. IVN: You Can't Blame Alaska's 'Decoy Dan' On Ranked Choice Voting
  3. IVN: How Republicans Flipped a Key Congressional Race Despite the Blue Wave in Maine

Adhere to the IVN etiquette

By posting a comment, you agree to adhere to our etiquette rules: No partisan attacks, no personal attacks, substantiate your sources, no self-promotion.

Get IVN’s Free Weekly Newsletter:Get IVN’s Free Newsletter

Get IVN’s Free Weekly Newsletter:Get IVN’s Free Newsletter

Nonpartisan Issues. Diverse Perspectives.

Check your inbox and click the link to confirm.

Republish this article

Republishing guidelines

Republish IVN articles for free. Independent Voter News articles may be republished online or in print under a Creative Commons BY-NC-ND 4.0 license, on these terms:

  1. Credit the author and IVN. Keep the byline ("By Author Name, Independent Voter News") and the attribution note at the end, which links to the original.
  2. Point search engines to the original. Set the canonical URL of your copy to the original IVN article (the HTML we give you includes the tag).
  3. Keep the meaning. You may update time and place references and apply your house style. You may trim for length, as long as the cuts don't change the meaning or misrepresent the author. Keep the headline. Mark any additions as your own (for example "Additional reporting by ...").
  4. Translations are welcome. Translate faithfully, add "Translated from English by [your outlet]", and tell us at editor@ivn.us.
  5. Keep the links, including the link to the original article.
  6. Keep the tracking image. The HTML includes a 1-pixel image that counts readers on your page. It collects no personal information.
  7. Photos and illustrations. Images credited to IVN may be used with this article only. Images credited to others (AP, Getty, Unsplash, Wikimedia and so on) stay under their owners' terms. Secure the rights or switch "Include images" off.
  8. Don't sell it. You can't sell our articles or sell ads specifically against them. Your normal site advertising is fine.
  9. No implied endorsement. Don't suggest that IVN or the author endorses you, your candidates or your causes, or that donations to you support IVN.
  10. Keep labels. Opinion or analysis pieces keep that label.
  11. No bulk or automated republishing, and don't submit our articles to aggregators (Apple News, Google News, MSN) as your own.
  12. Corrections and removals. Update your copy when we correct it, and remove it promptly if we ask. We'll contact you at the email you give us.
  13. Questions or print republication: editor@ivn.us.

IVN staff: fill in who you're inviting above, then create the invite.

Preparing the article

Alaska Democrats Won. Their Election Gamesmanship Didn't.

Choose a format
  • HTML
  • Email HTML
  • Markdown
  • Formatted (.docx)
  • Plain text
  • WordPress blocks
  • PDF
Choose a platform

Photos credited to others need their owners' permission.

To for

Republishing somewhere else? Questions? editor@ivn.us